Skip to content

Best Romance Books Compared

Jim's not ashamed to admit he's a sucker for a love story. Here are the best romance novels compared side by side — from slow burns to tearjerkers.

Book Rating
Pride and Prejudice Pride and Prejudice
5/5
Outlander Outlander
5/5
Beach Read Beach Read
4/5
Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine
5/5
Red, White & Royal Blue Red, White & Royal Blue
4/5
The Time Traveler's Wife The Time Traveler's Wife
4/5

Jim's Quick Takes

Pride and Prejudice

"Jim has to admit — he judged this book by its reputation as a "romance novel" and boy was he wrong. Austen's sass could cut diamonds. The verbal sparr..."

Read full review →

Outlander

"850 pages and Jim wanted MORE. Gabaldon built an entire world so rich this worm practically smelled the Scottish heather. The romance between Claire a..."

Read full review →

Beach Read

"Jim crawled through this book in one sitting and regrets nothing. Emily Henry nails the banter so hard it should be illegal, and the genre-swap bet is..."

Read full review →

Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine

"Eleanor is the most endearing oddball Jim has encountered since looking in a mirror. Honeyman peels back layers of social isolation with humor and dev..."

Read full review →

Red, White & Royal Blue

"A prince and a president's son fall in love and Jim is HERE for it. McQuiston writes banter that crackles like electricity and the forbidden romance a..."

Read full review →

The Time Traveler's Wife

"Jim's brain did backflips trying to track the timeline and loved every second. Niffenegger turns a sci-fi gimmick into the most achingly human love st..."

Read full review →